Tab I - Logistics

A. OVERVIEW

Logistics entail procuring, storing, and distributing materiel. During Gulf War military operations, distribution shortcomings frequently thwarted otherwise well-planned logistics. Distribution problems — i.e., getting materials to the units requesting them — affected pesticide availability and contributed to US forces’ widespread local purchase of certain pesticides in Saudi Arabia.

B. PESTICIDES ACCOMPANYING DEPLOYING UNITS

The Army, Navy, and Marine Corps authorized medical units to deploy with pesticide stocks; Air Force civil engineering units had the option to do this also. Evidence indicates Navy and Marine Corps medical units either deployed with pesticides or were able to obtain pesticides stockpiled in the theater before deployment.[798]

The Army authorized its units (companies, batteries, troops, and detachments) to establish field sanitation teams (FSTs) and stock pesticides for each team’s use. However, many units did not deploy with any pesticide stocks. The military authorized Army FSTs to stock the quantities in Table 133 in accordance with Field Manual (FM) 21-10-1.

Table 133. Army field sanitation team allowances[799]

ITEM

UNIT ISSUED

ALLOWED

Insect/Arthropod Repellent, DEET, Personal Application

Two Ounce Tube

384

Insecticide, Chlorpyrifos 42%

Box of 12 1.35 Ounce Bottles

1

Insecticide, d-Phenothrin, 2%

12 Ounce Can

144

Insecticide, Lindane 1% Dust

2 Ounce Bottle

192

Insecticide, Lindane 1% Dust

25 Pound Can

1

Rodenticide, Anticoagulant, Diphacinone

5 Pound Can

2

 

For the most part, Army units deploying from US installations were under the command of the Army’s Forces Command (FORSCOM) before deployment. Consequently, FORSCOM Regulation 700-2 authorized certain medical units and elements with a preventive medicine mission to pre-stock pesticides.

The Army used letter designations to distinguish the various medical detachments’ missions. "LA" meant the unit had an entomology mission. The 714th Medical Detachment (LA) was the only Army entomology unit to deploy. "LB" meant the unit performed more general preventive medicine missions and did not include entomologists. Tables 134 through 137 list these units’ pre-stocked pesticide allowances.[800]

Table 134 Army medical detachment (LA) pre-stocked pesticides

ITEM

UNIT ISSUED

ALLOWED

Fly Bait, Methomyl (Golden Malrin)

5 Pound Can

12

Insecticide, Chlorpyrifos EC 41%

5 Gallon Can

15

Insecticide, Diazinon 2% Dust

25 Pound Can

30

Insecticide, Lindane 1% Dust

25 Pound Can

20

Insecticide, Malathion 91%

5 Gallon Can

132

Rodenticide, Anticoagulant, Diphacinone

1 Pound Can

3

Rodenticide Bait, Ready Mix, Diphacinone

5 Pound Can

3

Rodenticide Bait, Quick Kill, Bromadiolone

11 Pound Can

45

 

Table 135. Army medical detachment (LB) pre-stocked pesticides

ITEM

UNIT ISSUED

ALLOWED

Insecticide, Chlorpyrifos 42%

Box of 12 1.35 Ounce Bottles

3

 

Table 136. Army division preventive medicine section (except airborne division) pre-stocked pesticides

ITEM

UNIT ISSUED

ALLOWED

Fly Bait, Methomyl (Golden Malrin),

5 Pound Can

8

Insecticide, Chlorpyrifos EC 41%

5 Gallon Can

1

Insecticide, Malathion 91%

5 Gallon Can

1

Rodenticide Bait, Quick Kill, Bromadiolone

11 Pound Can

5

Table 137. Army airborne division preventive medicine section pre-stocked pesticides

ITEM

UNIT OF ISSUE

ALLOWED

Fly Bait, Methomyl (Golden Malrin),

5 Pound Can

8

Insecticide, Chlorpyrifos EC 41%

5 Gallon Can

2

Insecticide, Malathion 91%

5 Gallon Can

2

Rodenticide Bait, Quick Kill, bromadiolone

11 Pound Can

5

 

C. PESTICIDES ORDERED FROM THE WHOLESALE SYSTEM

Units that ordered pesticides experienced military supply distribution problems virtually across the board. In November 1993, the Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) gave the Armed Forces Pest Management Board (AFPMB) data about the pesticides ordered for the Gulf War. Table 138 summarizes that data by service.[801]

A report from the US Navy Environmental Health Center’s preventive medicine team, which deployed between August 24 and October 14, 1990, summarized pesticide supplies as of October 25, 1990. The report did not identify quantities of pesticides by source. Supplies may have accompanied units deploying from home stations. Units also might have obtained supplies pre-positioned in Bahrain or other Navy locations, or may have ordered supplies specifically for Operation Desert Shield and received them in the Gulf.[802]

Because of the problems associated with using mists or fogs in desert winds, the Disease Vector Ecology and Control Center, Jacksonville (DVECC-JAX) emphasized residual and barrier emulsifiable concentrates (ECs). DVECC-JAX judged the 30 gallons of Dursban 4E and 200 gallons of 90 percent malathion EC stocked in the operations area (probably in Bahrain) was adequate to support six months of operations. DVECC-JAX believed residual wettable powders for use around latrines were en route, even though the quantities were not specified. DVECC-JAX reported the supplies on hand: 50 pounds each of two percent diazinon dust and one-percent lindane dust, 20 pounds of Talon rodenticide, and 10,800 tubes of DEET repellent cream. The sprayable permethrin repellent (also called permanone) for spraying uniforms, was on order, but the quantity was unspecified. Two thousand pounds of Fly Tek, a fly bait, were also on order.[803]

Table 138. Pesticides ordered from DLA

DESCRIPTION

Package

Unit of Issue

Theater Total

Army Totals

Army % of Theater Total

Air Force Totals

Air Force % of Theater Total

USMC Total

USMC % of Theater Total

Navy Totals

Navy % of Theater Total

Insect Repellent, clothing application, 75% DEET, 25% ethanol 2-oz bottle BT 54973 53132 96.65% 727 1.32% 1008 1.83% 106 0.19%
Insect Repellent, clothing application, aerosol (Permethrin Arthropod Repellent) (12) 6-oz cans BX 130894 113209 86.49% 8516 6.51% 8910 6.81% 259 0.20%
Insect Repellent, personal application, (3M/EPA 58007-1) (12) 2-oz tubes BX 112590 99185 88.09% 6840 6.08% 6271 5.57% 294 0.26%
Insect Repellent, personal application, 3% benzocaine, 10% precipitated sulfur (Chigg-Away) 118-ml bot. BT 3253 3253 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insect Repellent, personal application, 30% DEET (Cutter Insect Repellent Stick) (12) 1-oz tubes BX 1649 375 22.74% 1274 77.26% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Aluminum phosphide, 55% tablets (Phostoxin/Fumitoxin) 100 tablets CN 1 1 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Aluminum phosphide, 55% pellets (Phostoxin/Fumitoxin) 1660 pellets BT 12 12 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Baygon, 1% propoxur, liquid (Roach and Ant Spray) 1-gal can GL 833 745 89.44% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 88 10.56%
Insecticide, Baygon, 14.7% propoxur, emulsifiable concentrate (Baygon 1.5 EC) 1-gal can GL 58 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 58 100.00%
Baygon, (Propoxur) BX 4 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 4 100.00%
Insecticide, Boric Acid, aerosol (Whitmire PT 240 Perma-dust) (12) 16-oz cans BX 14 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 14 100.00%
Insecticide, Carbaryl, 80%, water dispersible powder (Sevin 80S) (5) 10-lb bags BX 3 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 3 100.00%
Insecticide, Carbaryl, 5%, dust (Sevin 5% dust) (12) 4-l b bags BX 56 56 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, 1.65% amidinohy-drazone, cockroach bait, large size (Combat) 8 bait stations/ box/12 PG 2 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 2 100.00%
Insecticide, 1.65% amidinohy-drazone, cockroach bait, regular size (Combat) 12 bait stations PG 64 14 21.88% 0 0.00% 1 1.56% 49 76.56%
Insecticide, Diazinon, 2%, dust 25-lb can CN 205 204 99.51% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 1 0.49%
Insecticide, Diazinon, 47.5%, emulsifiable concentrate 1-gal can GL 13 2 15.38% 0 0.00% 10 76.92% 1 7.69%
Insecticide, Dichlorvos, 20% (plastic strips) 48 strips BX 525 174 33.14% 334 63.62% 17 3.24% 0 0.00%
d-Phenothrin CN 143059 136175 95.19% 5774 4.04% 408 0.29% 702 0.49%
Insecticide, D-trans Allethrin and Resmethrin, 0.15% and 0.2% minimum, respectively, aerosol 11-oz can CN 14903 14561 97.71% 234 1.57% 0 0.00% 108 0.72%
Insecticide, Dursban, 42% chlorpyrifos, emulsifiable concentrate (Dursban 4E) 1-gal can GL 22 0 0.00% 12 54.55% 0 0.00% 10 45.45%
Insecticide, Dursban, 42.8% chlorpyrifos, emulsifiable concentrate (Dursban TC) (4) 1-gal cont. BX 360 0 0.00% 13 3.61% 0 0.00% 347 96.39%
Insecticide, Dursban, 42% chlorpyrifos, emulsifiable concentrate (Dursban 4E) 5-gal can CN 36 32 88.89% 4 11.11% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Dursban, 19.36% chlorpyrifos, liquid (Dursban 1.5 ULV) 5-gal can CN 39 0 0.00% 12 30.77% 0 0.00% 27 69.23%
Insecticide, Dursban, 0.5% chlorpyrifos, aerosol, (PT 279-Engage) (12) 20-oz cans BX 1 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 1 100.00%
Insecticide, Dursban 42% chlorpyrifos, emulsifiable concentrate (Dursban LO) (12) 40-ml bot. BX 3946 3940 99.85% 2 0.05% 0 0.00% 4 0.10%
Insecticide, Ficam, 76% bendiocarb, wettable powder (Ficam) 1-lb jar LB 15 12 80.00% 2 13.33% 1 6.67% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Fly Bait, 1% methomyl (Apache/Flytek/Golden Malrin) 5-lb can CN 18328 16810 91.72% 538 2.94% 858 4.68% 122 0.67%
Lindane 2 oz. can CN 111199 110983 99.81% 48 0.04% 120 0.11% 48 0.04%
Lindane 25 lb. can CN 3208 3208 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Malathion, 57.0%, emulsifiable concentrate, class 1 1-gal cont. GL 26 2 7.69% 0 0.00% 12 46.15% 12 46.15%
Insecticide, Malathion, 57.0%, emulsifiable concentrate, class 1 5-gal can CN 10 6 60.00% 4 40.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Malathion, 95%, liquid, grade B 54-gal drum DR 5 0 0.00% 4 80.00% 1 20.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Malathion, 95%, liquid, grade B 5-gal can CN 919 904 98.37% 10 1.09% 0 0.00% 5 0.54%
Pentachlorophenol CN 20 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 20 100.00%
Pyrethrin BX 19 10 52.63% 6 31.58% 2 10.53% 1 5.26%
Insecticide, Pyrethrins, 3% pyrethrins with synergists, liquid (ULV fog concentrate) 1-gal bot. GL 23 0 0.00% 18 78.26% 0 0.00% 5 21.74%
Insecticide, Pyrethrins, allethrin, d-phenothrin, or resmethrin, aerosol (PT 515 Wasp Freeze & Hornet Killer/ Wasp Stopper II Plus/Wasp & Hornet Killer II) (12) 12-oz can BX 8 0 0.00% 8 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Insecticide, Pyrethrin, aerosol (PT 565 Plus XLO) (12) 20-oz cans BX 344 276 80.23% 18 5.23% 46 13.37% 4 1.16%
Rodenticidal Bait, Anticoagulant, 0.005% diphacinone 40 blocks BX 10 10 100.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Rodenticidal Bait, Anticoagulant, 0.005-0.0055% diphacinone or 0.025-0.028% warfarin, pellets 5-lb can CN 5098 5085 99.74% 0 0.00% 6 0.12% 7 0.14%
Rodenticidal Bait, Anticoagulant, 0.005% bromadiolone (Maki), pellets 11-lb can CN 814 799 98.16% 15 1.84% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
Rodenticide, Anticoagulant, concentrate 0.05-0.055% diphacinone or 0.3-0.33% pindone or 0.5-0.55% 2-sovalery-1, 3-indandione 1-lb can LB 31 15 48.39% 16 51.61% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
* BT = Bottle, BX = Box, CN = Can, DR = drum, GL = gallon, LB = pound, OZ = ounces, PG = package

 

D. ORDERED PESTICIDES VERSUS APPLIED PESTICIDES

Table 139 shows the distribution of ordered pesticides by service. Table 140 shows the pesticides each service reported using based on analysis of the preventive medicine interviews.

Table 139. Summary of distribution of pesticides ordered from DLA

Types of Pesticides Used*

Army

Air Force

Navy/Marine Corps**

Emulsifiable Concentrates

Chlorpyrifos
Malathion

Malathion

Chlorpyrifos
Propoxur
Diazinon

Fogs (ULVs), Applicators only

Chlorpyrifos
Malathion

 

Chlorpyrifos

Pest strips

Dichlorvos

Dichlorvos

 
Delousers

Lindane

   
* Pesticides ranked by quantities reported in supply records
** Navy and Marines are combined as they shared supplies and personnel

 

Table 140. Distribution of pesticides based on applicator interviews*

Types of Pesticides Used

Army

Air Force

Navy/Marine Corps

Emulsifiable Concentrates

Chlorpyrifos
Diazinon
Malathion
Propoxur

Diazinon
Chlorpyrifos

Propoxur
Malathion
Chlorpyrifos
Diazinon

Fogs (ULVs) Applicators only

Chlorpyrifos
Malathion

 

Chlorpyrifos
Malathion

Pest strips

Dichlorvos

 

Dichlorvos

Delousers

Lindane

   
* Ranked by prevalence of reported use

 

These two tables show that Army and Air Force personnel apparently used diazinon EC extensively, despite the DLA records showing these same services ordered little or none. Similarly, the Army and Air Force ordered pest strips, but the Army, the Navy, and the Marine Corps primarily reported using them.

E. LOCAL PURCHASE

Supply distribution system shortcomings resulted in units facing shortages of many supply items, including pesticides. From the beginning of unit deployments through the end of combat operations, pesticide shortages were prevalent in the Army, Navy, and Marine Corps. Information available on Air Force problems is limited. However, Air Force units generally were co-located with Royal Saudi Air Force units, and several Air Force contacts have mentioned host nation pest control was prevalent on the Saudi Air Force bases.

When supplies were unavailable through military channels, organizations and individuals purchased pesticides locally. Preventive medicine and pest control personnel said fly control products were the pesticides most frequently purchased locally, followed by rodent control products. The Navy’s local purchase requirements varied more than the other services’ requirements, probably due to greater mosquito exposure.

Preventive medicine and pest control personnel most frequently mentioned SNIP fly bait as the top local purchase item. According to the 1st Force Service Support Group entomologist, who was the 1st Marine Expeditionary Force’s pesticide purchase approval authority, SNIP and Alfacron were the only two products authorized for Marine units’ local purchase.[804] Though he did not recall the product’s name, an officer who served with the 2nd Battalion, 505th Parachute Infantry Regiment, 82nd Airborne Division, recalled purchasing a fly bait he described as yellow granules, a description consistent with SNIP. This officer did not recall who had briefed him on his duties as a purchasing agent, but said he received no guidance on pesticides he could or could not purchase.[805] The commander of a maintenance unit with the Army’s 2nd Armored Cavalry Regiment reported his unit used SNIP. He believed his unit received SNIP on a "push" basis, i.e., the regiment issued it to the unit.[806]

In an April 1991 situation report, the 12th Medical Detachment reported that insect infestations, especially fly infestations, were increasing, and "few, if any, pesticides...[were] available in the supply system." The 12th Medical Detachment advised the units it supported about local pesticide purchasing sources.[807] In an undated, single-page flyer, the 983rd Medical Detachment recommended substitutes available from the local economy in the Dammam area. This flyer identified three rodenticides, two fly baits, and a larvacide (for mosquito larva) available from two different suppliers in Dammam. The flyer stated that ordering officers had to obtain approval to purchase these items "through normal channels."[808]

A Navy entomologist recalled the local purchase of 95% malathion, pyrethroids (possibly cypermethrin or deltamethrin), fly baits (including Fly Tek and SNIP), and a brand of permethrin.[809] A second Navy entomologist reported purchasing SNIPonly,[810] while a third recalled both SNIP and Alfacron, the wettable powder form of azamethiphos. A Navy environmental science officer mentioned Baygon (propoxur) and malathion as being locally purchased. The only other locally purchased product mentioned by Navy preventive medicine personnel was Ficam (bendiocarb).[811] Air Force pest controllers most prominently mentioned fly bait and rodenticide.[812] The only product mentioned that was not a fly bait or rodenticide was an aerosol containing permethrin.[813]

In August 1991, the Army’s Preventive Medicine Detachment, Southwest Asia, distributed a memorandum cautioning unit commanders to ensure that untrained personnel did not procure, possess, or apply pesticides, except for Permanone (permethrin) and d-phenothrin. This guidance permitted field sanitation teams (FSTs) to apply chlorpyrifos and use fly baits, such as Flytek and Apache.[814] The memorandum’s author, an entomologist, wrote it because the flyer identifying locally available substitutes had listed pesticides that untrained personnel (those who were not certified pest controllers) could not legally purchase in the United States. This memorandum also enabled the entomologist to monitor pest control requirements beyond FSTs’ qualifications.[815]

Locally purchased pesticides were sometimes labeled in Arabic. A Navy entomologist and an Army environmental science officer both said without qualification that US forces used pesticides labeled in Arabic.[816]

Pest controllers and preventive medicine specialists and technicians dealt with the problem of labels they could not read in various ways. In some cases the label identified ingredients in English so applicators used that information to determine what to do.[817] Several applicators obtained demonstrations or translations by local personnel.[818] Others relied on senior personnel for guidance.[819] One applicator stated she handled an unknown pesticide without guidance.[820]

F. SUMMARY

The US military supply system included a variety of pesticides and repellents used throughout the Kuwait Theater of Operations. However, it became necessary to purchase locally available pesticides due to depleted inventory supplies or delays in distribution. As a result, US servicemembers purchased a variety of pesticides from local vendors. Some pesticides, including fly baits, may have been similar to those in the US supply system. In addition, some of these local pesticides may not have been registered with the EPA or may have had labels requiring translation into English. In 1999, The Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Technology published guidance on the local purchase of pesticides during military deployments that provides for the proper review and approval of locally purchased pesticides.[821]


| First Page | Prev Page | Next Page |